Introduction
Powers of attorney are used by individuals and corporates to facilitate the entry into a wide variety of documents and transactions.
The utility of a power of attorney is recognised by the common law and by statute (including s. 10 of the Powers of Attorney Act 1971 and s. 47 of the Companies Act 2006).
However, the powers conferred on the recipient of a power of attorney are necessarily constrained by the terms of the instrument which creates the power.
Background
On 26 November 2020, a limited partnership (the “Limited Partnership”) which described itself as the “Conscious Fund” was created pursuant to a limited partnership agreement (the “LPA”).
This was a private fund limited partnership under the Limited Partnerships Act 1907, as amended by The Legislative Reform (Private Fund Limited Partnerships) Order 2017 (2017 No. 514).
The LPA was entered into between (1) TCF 1 GP Limited (the “General Partner”) (2) an initial limited partner (3) an investment manager and (4) the limited partners listed in a Schedule to the LPA (the “Limited Partners”).
Relevant clauses
Clause 10 of the LPA conferred on the General Partner the ability to make investments through parallel investment vehicles.
The clause required each Limited Partner to take such actions and execute any documents which the General Partner determined were necessary to accomplish the purposes of the business of the Limited Partnership and to give effect to clause 10.
In addition, the clause also listed some of the powers which the General Partner was able to exercise on behalf of the Limited Partners to achieve that stated objective. For example, the General Partner had authority to execute all deeds and documents which were necessary or appropriate to facilitate the formation and on-going operation of a parallel investment vehicle and to transfer investments to such a vehicle.
To reinforce these powers, the LPA also contained a power of attorney. By clause 26, each Limited Partner appointed the General Partner to be its attorney for the purpose of entering into any deeds and documents required by clause 10.
Furthermore, the General Partner was empowered to enter into any deed or document that (amongst other things) was required to be filed by the Limited Partnership or the Limited Partners under the laws of any jurisdiction:
- to reflect the dissolution or termination of the Limited Partnership or the Limited Partnership being governed by any amendment or successor statute to the law; or
- to reorganise or re-file the Limited Partnership in a different jurisdiction “on condition that reorganisation or re-filing does not result in a material change in the rights of” the Limited Partners.
Despite describing itself as an agreement, the LPA stated that it was intended to be executed as a deed. The reason for making this statement was that it enabled the instrument to comply with the formalities required for the execution of a deed.
This was important because s. 1(1) of the Powers of Attorney Act 1971 requires an instrument which creates a power of attorney to be executed as a deed. The statutory requirements for the execution of a deed by a company are set out in s. 1(2) of the Law of Property (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 1989 and s. 44 of the Companies Act 2006.
Dispute
At some point, the General Partner decided that the Limited Partnership should be redomiciled in the Cayman Islands.
The General Partner would later tell the High Court that it had decided to do so because most of the Limited Partners were based in the USA, that most of its assets were situated there and that it operated, and denominated its rights, in US currency.
The general partner sought to achieve its stated objective in two ways:
- it attempted to amend the LPA by changing the governing law from England to the Cayman Islands and by changing the forum for the resolution of disputes from the courts of England and Wales to the courts of the Cayman Islands; and
- it executed a new limited partnership agreement (the “Cayman LPA”) that was governed by the laws of the Cayman Islands and, also, presented that agreement for registration to the appropriate Cayman authority.
Proceedings
The claimant was one of the Limited Partners and was a company incorporated in Malta.
It disagreed with the General Partner’s attempt to redomicile the Limited Partnership in the Cayman Islands and sought a declaration from the High Court that the Limited Partnership remained governed by English law.
Judgment
The High Court decided, having reviewed the relevant documents, that the claimant remained bound by the LPA and had not become bound by the Cayman LPA.
The greater part of the judgment (paras. 18 to 85) focused on the question of whether the LPA had been duly executed as a deed by the claimant and, by implication, whether the power of attorney contained in the LPA was valid. The court decided that the LPA had not been executed as a deed because the statutory formalities referred to above had not been complied with.
It should, however, be noted that the judgment did not consider The Overseas Companies (Execution of Documents and Registration of Charges) Regulations 2009 (2009 No. 1917) which adopt and modify s. 44 of the Companies Act 2006 in the case of companies incorporated overseas, such as the claimant.
Other findings
We turn now to some of the other questions the court was called on to decide, which relate to the scope and extent of the power of attorney in the LPA. These include the following:
- Question 1: whether the power of attorney in the LPA could take effect as a contract between the parties, even though it failed as a deed.
- Question 2: whether the scope of the power of attorney was wide enough to enable the General Partner to redomicile the Limited Partnership to the Cayman Islands.
- Question 3: whether the Cayman LPA had, in fact, been executed by the defendant as the attorney of each Limited Partner, including the claimant.
- Question 4: assuming the answer to the previous question is “yes”, whether the amendment made to the LPA resulted in a material change to the rights of the partners in the Limited Partnership.
Question 1
The judge (HHJ Paul Matthews, sitting as a judge of the High Court) noted that there was a body of case law which established that a document which failed to satisfy the formalities of a deed could still create a valid contract between the parties.
Having reviewed several of those authorities, he concluded that the Powers of Attorney Act 1971 required that an instrument which created a power of attorney had to be made by deed and that nothing less would do.
Question 2
The judge decided that the power of attorney contained in clause 26 of the LPA was not drafted in a manner which enabled the General Partner to enter into a new limited partnership agreement governed by the laws of the Cayman Islands.
The judge accepted (at para. 120) that the power of attorney in clause 26 enabled the defendant (as attorney for the Limited Partners) to execute documents which reflected a change to the terms of the LPA but did not enable it to make that change. He also observed (at para. 122) that:
Clause 26 of the English LPA confers power on the defendant only to
execute documents required by local law for the reorganisation or
refiling of the English partnership. It therefore comes into
operation as an implementation mechanism only after a valid decision
has been taken that the English partnership should be re-domiciled
elsewhere. It does not itself confer the power to decide to
re-domicile the English partnership.
Question 3
The judge accepted the argument advanced by the claimant that the defendant had not actually signed the Cayman LPA as attorney either separately for each Limited Partner or for all of the Limited Partners listed in that agreement.
Upon a close consideration of the terms of the Cayman LPA and the execution blocks in it, the judge noted that the defendant had signed on behalf of the Cayman limited partnership, rather than the Limited Partners themselves. He observed (at para. 129) that if clause 26 of the LPA were a valid and effective power of attorney, it had not been exercised in accordance with its terms “and hence was an invalid exercise.”
Question 4
Even if the power of attorney had been drafted in a manner that enabled the General Partner to redomicile or re-file the Limited Partnership in the Cayman Islands, the terms of the LPA provided that the General Partner would be unable to do so if and to the extent that it would amount to a material change to the rights of the partners.
The judge decided that changes to the governing law and jurisdiction clauses of the LPA would amount to a material change in the rights of the partners. He commented that an investor contemplating an investment in a partnership would consider it important to know how and where its rights could be enforced “in the event that things went wrong” and added (at para. 134) that:
Depending on the investor’s base and culture, some places and means of
enforcement are more attractive than others. In my judgment, an entry
into the Cayman LPA from the English LPA would indeed effect a
material change in the rights of the partners. Procedural it may be,
but, in my judgment, it is a case of moving the goalposts after the
ball has been kicked.
Conclusion & practical implications
The judgment in the 3Kings case rewards closer reading for several important reasons.
As a general observation, the judgment demonstrates the importance of (1) complying with the requisite formalities when it comes to granting a power of attorney and (2) carefully reviewing the terms of the power before entering into a transaction, or executing a document, in reliance on it.
The judgment is of particular relevance for financing transactions. Powers of attorney are important documents for both lenders and financiers because they form part of a chain of authorisations. The practical lesson for lenders and financiers, and those advising them, is to check (amongst other things) that the donor of a power of attorney has the capacity to grant it, that it has been properly authorised and executed, that it refers to the correct transactions and documents, that it names the relevant signatories and that it is exercised in accordance with its terms.









