We’re making some changes at Simmons & Simmons to how we send newsletters to help keep your inbox tidy. Going forward, our Disputes Views will be shared through our Weekly Insights digest – so please make sure you’re signed up if you want to keep receiving these updates.
We bring you our November edition of the Disputes View, which brings fresh warnings on the use of AI in court proceedings, cases on a range of topics from Quincecare duties and finance broker commissions to the enforcement of investor / state treaty awards and the latest from the FCA.
AI in the courts
AI witness coaching warning
A criminal trial was stayed as an abuse of process after it was discovered that the complainant had asked an AI chatbot to help her prepare for cross-examination and suggest answers to likely questions. The Court of Appeal held that the trial could proceed because there was also untainted evidence and the jury could take account of what had occurred, but stated that witnesses must be warned not to use AI to help them prepare to give evidence. This applies equally to civil cases, where evidence would likely be excluded if AI coaching was found to have occurred.
Expert’s use of AI criticised
The judge in a Family Court trial held that she was unable to place any significant reliance upon an expert’s report drafted using AI. This was despite the expert’s assurance of independence and oversight, although that was undermined by an AI generated drafting comment that had been left in the report. In a recent speech, Joanna Smith J, the interim Head of the Business and Property Division of the High Court, has encouraged expert witnesses to disclose any use of AI in their work, ahead of likely rule changes requiring declarations by experts and witnesses.
Civil Justice Council makes recommendations on AI in court documents
The Civil Justice Council has published its report following a consultation on the use of AI in court documents. The Council recommends that documents produced by lawyers need not contain declarations as to AI use, due to the oversight of the professions by their respective regulators, each of whom has published guidance on AI use that emphasises professionals’ responsibility for any documents they produce. Ther report recommends declarations on any AI use that affects the substance of witness statements or expert evidence.
Cases
No Quincecare duty found
In Moorwand v Hamblin the Court of Appeal held that a High Court judge had erred in allowing an appeal against the dismissal of a claim brought against an electronic money institution by the victims of an authorised push payment fraud. The first-instance judge's decision that the institution had not been put on enquiry, meaning that its Quincecare duty not to execute payment orders had not arisen, had been one that was open to him on the evidence and the high threshold for interfering with his evaluative assessment on appeal had not been met.
Finance broker entitled to commissions
The Court of Appeal held in Alphier Capital Two LLP v Blyvoor Gold Capital (Pty) Ltd that a finance broker, engaged alongside another broker to help obtain funding for their client from a particular investor, was entitled under the parties' agreement to receive commission. Even though the other broker had introduced the investor, the finance broker’s actions had a practical effect in securing the investment and did not need to be the effective cause of the investment.
Court of Appeal rules on PPI indemnity and limits of Contribution Act
In AXA France IARD S.A. v Santander Cards UK Ltd the Court of Appeal held that, properly construed, an indemnity given by the bank in an agreement with AXA in 2000 related to prospective acts or omissions only and did not cover mis-selling that occurred prior to the agreement. A cross-appeal challenging the judge’s conclusion that Santander was not “liable” for damage suffered by PPI complainants under the Contribution Act failed: complaints were not “claims” in the sense of claims filed at court and the Contribution Act applies only to liability for claims.
Assignee of ICSID award cannot enforce in England and Wales
In Blasket Renewable Investments LLC v Kingdom of Spain the Court of Appeal held that, under customary international law, treaty rights are not assignable without the consent of the obligor state and that position is equally applicable to rights under an ICSID Convention award. The claimant litigation funders had purchased the benefit of an award against the Kingdom of Spain under the Energy Charter Treaty relating to changes to the country’s renewable energy incentive schemes. Simmons acted for the Kingdom of Spain.
Privilege when lawyers are investigated by the SRA
The High Court decision in Carter-Ruck v Solicitors Regulation Authority deals with the narrow but important question of whether the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) can obtain client material from a solicitor's file that is subject to legal professional privilege (LPP), using its statutory powers under section 44B of the Solicitors Act 1974.
Since 1969, the industry has operated on the premise that when the SRA is investigating a law firm’s conduct, even where the client has not complained to the SRA (so has not waived privilege) the SRA is entitled to require the law firm to produce the client’s privileged materials for the purposes of the investigation. Butcher J has now held that s.44B does not give the SRA that power.
Butcher J held that LPP is a ‘fundamental right’ of law firms’ clients and that if Parliament had intended section 44B to erode that right, they would have said so. As for the SRA’s view that sharing privileged materials with it as regulator occurs in a protected environment which does not infringe the client’s privilege, Butcher J said that argument had been addressed and rejected by the Court of Appeal, when they considered the powers of the Financial Reporting Council in 2021, in Sports Direct.
Undoubtedly this will make the SRA’s job more difficult, but it is worth remembering that the issue will not arise in SRA investigations triggered by a client’s complaint, where LPP is waived impliedly or explicitly.
Court procedure
New Business and Property Division
Since 01 October 2026, the new Business and Property Division has been in operation, replacing the Chancery Division and incorporating the Commercial Court and Technology and Construction Court. The various specialist lists, including the Financial List, remain the same. Guidance on headings for court documents was published in a Practice Note.
Disclosure changes likely
The Disclosure Review Working Group has published the results of a stakeholder survey into satisfaction with Practice Direction 57AD, which covers disclosure in Business and Property Court proceedings. Opinions were divided on many issues, but there was widespread concern that the costs of disclosure were too high and that disputes over the scope of disclosure had increased rather than decreased. The Working Group has concluded that a return to the previous disclosure rules would not be appropriate, but that changes to simplify the PD57AD regime are needed. Proposals for changes will be published either late in 2026 or early in 2027.
From the FCA
Man sentenced over £154m fake takeover bid targeting UK-listed company
Christopher Woolcott pleaded guilty to 4 counts of fraud and forgery after creating a fake takeover bid for Touchstone Exploration Inc in an effort to increase the value of his own shareholding in the company. He was handed a 2 year prison sentence, suspended for two years with conditions including the completion of 200 hours unpaid work.
Motor finance legal challenge to be heard in February 2027
FCA sets expectations for firms making car finance settlement offers
In the world of motor finance commission and the FCA’s attempt to impose a s404 redress scheme there have been two interesting developments. First the judicial review challenge has been set down for February 2027. Second, the FCA has set out guidance for firms who wish to make compensation offers to customers now. Broadly, the FCA are supportive of early offers as long as they are no less favourable than the customer would be entitled to under the FCA’s scheme, and the customer is made aware of that they can await the result of the legal challenge and that may mean result or more or less redress being due.
FCA opens investigation into Euro Exchange Securities UK Ltd
The FCA has announced another investigation, this time into Euro Exchange Securities UK Ltd, an e-money firm, due to money laundering systems and controls concerns
Consumers warned to beware of risky mini-bonds and loan notes
The FCA has been warning consumers about unregulated mini-bonds for over 7 years. In the wake of the recent failure of Woodville Consultants Ltd, a litigation funder that raised capital from retail investors through unregulated loan notes, the FCA is repeating its warning that consumers should be aware of the risks of investing. This is despite the FCA’s ban on marketing speculative illiquid investments, including mini-bonds, to retail customers on 1 January 2021.


.jpg?crop=300,495&format=webply&auto=webp)

.jpg?crop=300,495&format=webply&auto=webp)




.jpeg?crop=300,495&format=webply&auto=webp)



_(1)_11zon.jpg?crop=300,495&format=webply&auto=webp)




